Explain why the idea of 'postmodern media' might be considered controversial. [50 marks]

Postmodernism is a late 20^th Century movement that labels a cultural form displaying different qualities, represents the departure of modernism and is a way of mixing different styles and media.

Controversy is an ongoing discussion about ideas conflicting with the norm. This can be applied to postmodernism in different ways and different media’s. We can use self-reflexivity as an example of a controversial postmodern style. The audience can be unhappy that the film is revealed. They came to watch a film and are jolted back to reality throughout. This can occur when an actor breaks the 4^th wall, an example of this would be the film The Wolf Of Wall Street (Martin Scorsese 2013) when Leonardo DiCaprio looks directly into the camera and talks to the audience, like he is telling them a story. Other ways a film can be self-reflexive is when the set is reviled to the viewers and they are suddenly snapped back to realising that they are watching a film and aren’t at all involved. A great example of this is when the character Shoshana in the film Inglorious Basterds (Quentin Tarantino 2009) is walking through the corridors or the cinema, on the way to the film premiere, a crane shot is used to follow her. As it is shot from above we see the tops of walls on all the corridors and the set is revealed. Some viewers like the idea of self-reflexivity but others don’t want to be placed back into reality which is why it’s considered controversial.

Controversial postmodern media’s can also stretch to music videos too. The M.I.A music video for the song Born Free was extremely controversial. On element that makes the video postmodern is that it contains intertextual references. In the video there is a bus which has bars across the windows and is attacked by a ginger guy throwing bricks or stones at the bars. This references the scene from the film Billy Elliot which is about the miners’ strike. There were riots on the street, with a bus with bars across the windows driving through, getting attacked. The other postmodern this about the video, not only does it contain intertextuality, it parodies the situation. The reference was to do with the miners’ strike, but the video twists it to be about persecution of ginger haired people. Using parody can cause offence, which makes the video controversial. Other examples of this are Southpark and Family Guy, they cross the line all the time but persecute everyone. This shows that the video is postmodern. The reason it is controversial is that the video is all about persecution of the gingers. Several gingers grouped together on a bus, made to run through a mine field and blown it. There is gritting violence and limbs flying around and blood everywhere which makes the video massively controversial. The reasoning behind making a video like this is to gain publicity.

Sampling in music is also considered controversial and postmodern as it is basically taking credit for someone else’s work. Sampling is used all the time in the music industry, examples include; Aloe Blacc sampled Elton John for the song I’m the man, Chase and Status sampled The doors song Down so god Damn Long for their single Hypest Hype and The Klaxons sampled their old songs for their new album, which could be considered really controversial as its recycling old ideas. Sampling in a sense is like intertextual references in videos, examples of intertextual references can be like the film Drive (Nicholas Winding Refn 2011) referencing San Andreas, the film Holy Motors references the film Eyes Without a Face with the limousine driver wearing the same mask at the end of Holy Motors as she work in the film Eyes Without a Face.

In the future, I think one postmodern idea that will develop is the use of holograms in music. We already see holograms being used but, I think what will start to happen is dead pop or rock stars will be put into a super band. E.G. Elvis Presley, Jimmy Hendrix etc. all put into a band to perform as holograms. This could be considered a really controversial idea in that they were all famous and now they are all dead, so the idea could be construed as disrespectful to them and their families.